MECHANICAL VS. DISCRETIONARY TRADING Paired futures replay worksheet 1. Write the plan before opening the session. Contract, date, session and time zone: Setup version and exact qualification rule: Allowed discretionary veto and what would justify it: Position, per-trade and session loss limits: Fill, commission and slippage assumptions: Treatment of missing data and unresolved fills: 2. Record the decision before revealing the next bar. Signal time and setup evidence: Mechanical decision (take / blocked / unknown): Decision with discretion (take / veto / blocked / unknown): Veto observation or applicable account limit: Open positions and session risk room in each version: 3. After advancing, record both outcomes. Mechanical entry, exit and modeled net result: Discretionary entry, exit and modeled net result: Unresolved order or price sequence: 4. Review the same list in both versions. Count setup opportunities, taken trades, vetoes, risk blocks and unknown outcomes separately. A deliberate skip with no order has zero modeled P&L. Unresolved fills stay unknown. Compare net per setup and net per executed trade. Report the sample count and costs alongside each figure. If trades can overlap or session limits depend on earlier outcomes, track positions and risk room separately for each version. A decision blocked by the one-position limit belongs in the log even when the other version could take that setup. Guide: https://trade-reign.com/mechanical-vs-discretionary-trading