TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Trading Psychology

A+ Trading Setup Checklist Grade the Signal and Check the Entry

An A+ setup is a label from your playbook. In this fictional MES exercise, A and A+ use the same execution limits. The extra observations determine the grade and give you something specific to compare in later reviews.

Quick Answer

Define the trade requirements and quality criteria before the session. Grade the signal when its confirmation bar closes. Then check the available entry against your maximum price and risk budget. An A+ grade can still lead to a skip.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides

Three replays of a breakout retest

Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.

The 10:15 retest closes near the high. The modeled next entry is 6,005.50. The planned stop at 6,000.00 is reached in the bar ending at 10:40. The grading criteria were all available earlier.

Required setup

Price breaks 6,004.00, revisits 6,004.00–6,005.00 and closes back above 6,004.00.

A+ quality checks

The retest low is within one tick of 6,004.00 and its close is in the upper quarter of the candle.

Execution check

Use the same $30 limit and 6,005.50 maximum entry regardless of the grade.

Grade the A+ and A setups at 10:15 a.m. ET

Write down the breakout reference at 6,004.00, the stop at 6,000.00 and the 6,012.00 target before the replay. The bar ending at 10:05 closes above the breakout level. Check the next two closes for the retest. In both setups the 10:15 low enters the planned band of 6,004.00–6,005.00 and the candle closes back above the level.

The tight retest has a 6,004.25 low, a 6,005.75 high and a 6,005.50 close. The low comes within one tick of the breakout level. Its close is 1.25 points above the low in a 1.50-point bar, or about 83% up the bar. Both quality checks pass, so the sample scores A+.

The wider retest closes at the same 6,005.50, with a 6,004.50 low and a 6,006.25 high. The low is two ticks above the breakout level and the close is about 57% up the bar. The required setup still passes and the sample scores A. Decide which grades your test allows before replaying an entry.

Calculate the highest entry the plan allows

One MES costs $5 per point of adverse movement. With a hypothetical $2 cost allowance and a $30 risk cap, the available stop distance is ($30 − $2) ÷ $5 = 5.60 points. Round the distance down to 5.50 points on the 0.25-point tick grid. With a 6,000.00 stop, the highest price this exercise allows is 6,005.50.

At the next modeled entry of 6,005.50, the estimated loss at the stop is $29.50. If the first available price is 6,006.25, the estimate rises to $33.25 and the exercise skips. This replay checks only the first available entry after confirmation and leaves no working order. The chart later reaches 6,012.00. Record that path as a correct skip under the written rule.

Use the prices as fictional observations. The bar open is a proxy for the first available price in this example. In a real log, write down the quote or execution you can verify and any fees or slippage. A stop order can fill beyond its trigger price.

Log the grade before the outcome

Keep one row per observed candidate. Write the rule version, decision time, required conditions, quality observations, grade, available price, estimated risk, and action. Then reveal the next bars and record any outcome separately.

Review A and A+ samples with the same cost model. Include stops, targets, skips, missed signals and unknowns. Before changing a grade threshold, use a separate set of unseen examples to check whether the change helps. The three paths are fictional exercises with shared bars.

Fictional replay log for a plan that allows A and A+
GradeActionLater observation
A+Modeled entryStop reached
AModeled entryStop reached
A+Skip, entry above capTarget level reached without entry
Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

CME Group on entry and exit criteriaDefine when a setup becomes eligible and when to leave it alone.CME Group on risk in a trading planSpecify separate trade and day limits before execution.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Mechanical vs. discretionary trading

Test whether two reviewers can apply the same entry rule.

Futures trading journal template

Record the original rule and audit decisions before revealing P&L.

Calculate risk per trade

Check the stop, costs and estimated dollar risk from the available entry.

Tell a correct skip from trading hesitation

Compare the decision with the entry rules that were in force.

FAQ

Common Questions

Is there one universal A+ trading setup?

The grade comes from criteria in a specific playbook. This worksheet uses two retest measurements to illustrate how a trader can grade consistently before entry.

Can an A+ setup still be a correct skip?

Yes. In the example, the signal earns A+ at confirmation. The first modeled entry price exceeds the written cap, so the action is to skip even though price reaches the target later.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.