TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Futures Trade Review

Futures Trading Journal Template and Worked Example

Use the template to compare the trade you planned with the trade you actually took. Use fills and costs to reconcile the result, and review plan adherence in a separate pass with net P&L hidden.

Quick Answer

For each trade, record the account, contract expiry, planned risk, actual fills, and costs. Then note whether you followed the plan and choose one action to check next session. When you scaled out, include each exit quantity and fill price.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides

Copy this trade review template

Trading session and time zone:
Account and environment:
Contract and expiry:
Planned entry, quantity, stop, and targets:
Planned risk in dollars before costs:
Actual entry and exit fills with times and quantities:
Gross P&L, total fees, and net P&L:
Net result in R (net P&L divided by initial planned risk):
Plan followed (yes, partially, or no):
One action to check next session:

Plan

Record the original entry, position size, and exit rules before the trade.

Result

Use individual fills and fees to reconcile the completed position.

Review

Score what you can verify before looking at P&L.

Worked MES example with a partial exit

Suppose your plan is to buy two MES contracts at 6,000.00 with a stop at 5,996.00 and take one contract off at 6,004.00. That initial stop is four points away. At $5 per point per contract, the planned stop distance represents $40 before fees or slippage.

Both contracts fill at 6,000.00. One exits at 6,004.00 and the other at 5,998.00. The first adds $20 and the second loses $10, leaving $10 gross. If the total fees for the two contracts are $3, the result is $7 net. If you copied the result from a report that already includes costs, use that net figure without subtracting fees again.

The $7 net result divided by the original $40 risk gives +0.175R for the closed position. Keep the initial risk for both contracts in the denominator when grouping their exits as one decision.

Suppose you moved the second exit early out of fear, before the change was allowed by your plan. Mark the review Partially followed despite the $7 profit. One next-session check could read: after the first target fills, confirm the remaining stop quantity and compare any later adjustment with the written rule.

Reconcile the entries before reviewing your decisions

Start with the intended account and contract expiry. For a routed account, the broker's fills can resolve a mismatch between chart markers and your journal. If you exported the same brokerage account through two platforms, use one record for overlapping fills.

Be consistent when counting trades. A report can pair one entry with several exits and show each pair as a completed row. If your journal treats the position from first entry until flat as one trading decision, keep those partial exits together for the decision review. Keep each copied account's P&L separate when evaluating account results.

Check for outcome bias in your trading journal

Outcome bias is judging a decision differently after learning how it turned out. In a series of experiments, Jonathan Baron and John Hershey found that people rated the thinking behind a decision more favorably when the result was favorable. In a journal, hide the net P&L column on the first pass. Keep the plan, order timestamps, fills, and any chart evidence you need to check what happened. Work from the rule that was in force when each decision was made.

Take three fictional one-contract MES trades under the same plan. An entry order must be sent by 10:30 a.m. ET, and the original six-point stop must stay in place unless the written exit rule calls for a change. Trade A has a 10:24 submission and follows the stop rule. Trade B has a 10:34 submission and follows the stop rule. Trade C follows the stop rule, but its report gives only a fill time, which does not establish whether the order was sent by 10:30.

Before revealing the result, record on time, late, and unknown for the submission rule. One of the two verifiable submissions was on time, with one of three submissions unknown. Now reveal the hypothetical net results. A lost $33, B made $42, and C made $12. The $42 winner still missed the cutoff. The $33 loss still followed both rules. If late submissions recur, compare the alert and order times in the next review. Keep the full P&L, including trades with unknown evidence, when reviewing account performance.

Set a Process Goal for Your Weekly Trading Review

A process goal names a behavior you can practice and check. An outcome goal names a result, such as weekly net P&L. For example, set a process goal to log take or pass for each eligible setup before its next five-minute candle closes. Save the written eligibility rule and include valid passes as well as entries. Use the replay or a complete setup log to count opportunities because a fills report omits passes.

Suppose a simulated week has 12 eligible decisions. You verify eight were logged on time and two were logged late. For the remaining two, timestamps are missing. On-time adherence is 8 out of 10 verifiable decisions, or 80%. Evidence covers 10 out of 12. Keep both counts visible so an incomplete journal cannot make the process look more consistent. If a session has no eligible signals, record zero opportunities. If you cannot establish whether a session had signals, mark its coverage as unknown.

Review the two late decisions with P&L hidden and log the actual reason for each. If both happened while switching charts, try one change next week, such as keeping the decision log beside the chart. Test the change with the same deadline and report coverage again. Reconcile net P&L separately using the full set of fills.

Week, strategy version, and sessions reviewed:
Process goal and decision deadline:
Eligible decisions (including planned skips):
Verified on time / verified late / unknown:
On-time rate among verified decisions:
Evidence coverage across all eligible decisions:
One change to try on the next practice session:

Use TradeReign’s P&L Journal for a daily review

For a supported Tradovate account, select the intended account in TradeReign and open P&L Journal. In Current Account, select the session date to open its review. Check the displayed P&L source and any rule violations, then record plan adherence and use the setup, emotion, and mistake tags that apply.

At the end of the week, scan your notes and violations for a pattern, such as closing early on profitable days. Use the pattern to choose a single behavior to review next week. If you're reviewing past prop-account attempts, use Overall Journey and check the coverage and source of the saved history before comparing results.

Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

CME Group on keeping a trade logHow to record trade context and review the reasons behind results.Baron and Hershey’s outcome bias experimentsHow favorable results affected ratings of decision quality.CME MES contract specificationsThe multiplier and tick size used in the example.NinjaTrader on journaling futures tradesRecording trade context and reviewing recurring behavior.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Compare early and late decisions in your journal

Use matched setup candidates and record filled and unfilled orders separately.

Compare trading windows in your journal

Test one setup across two time blocks and retain plans, fills and skips.

Compare two trading plans in the same replay

Download a worksheet that tracks decisions, vetoes and account limits separately.

Review a trading losing streak

Compare consecutive losses, execution deviations, and the remaining risk limit.

Audit early exits and wider stops

Compare each exit change with the rule in force before the trade.

Check overconfidence after a win

Compare planned and proposed risk, then journal the first eligible setup after a win.

Review trading hesitation

Distinguish an eligible miss from a rules-based skip in a worked replay.

Test a session stop against your journal

Compare a P&L threshold and a trade cap against the same sequence of closed trades.

Check a session loss breach between fills

Compare two charts with the same closing P&L and different session-stop outcomes.

Journal mechanical signals and discretionary skips

Use one row per eligible signal to compare decisions on the same setups.

Export Tradovate trade history to CSV

Keep execution prices and quantities when adding trade costs to the journal.

Reconcile a completed trade’s net futures P&L

Match fills and costs before recording the result in your journal.

Calculate MAE and MFE for a futures trade

Measure the worst and best price moves during the trade using a worked MES chart.

Calculate trading expectancy in dollars and R

Use closed-trade results and original planned risk to compare both averages after costs.

Compare profit factor with expectancy

See how taking more risk can increase dollars per trade even when profit factor falls.

Export NinjaTrader trades to CSV

Choose Executions or Trades and reconcile partial fills.

Export TradingView trade history

Check canceled orders for partial fills before importing.

Evaluate a futures stop adjustment

Calculate how widening a stop changes the planned exposure.

FAQ

Common Questions

Should I journal closed trades or individual fills?

Use fills to verify quantities, prices, and partial exits. Use a consistent grouping rule when you review trading decisions, such as grouping the fills from first entry until flat.

How do I account for futures commissions in my journal?

Record gross P&L and subtract the total fees once. If your source already reports net P&L, record its basis and avoid subtracting those fees again.

Can I use the template without TradeReign?

Yes. Copy the fields into any notes app or journal and fill them in using your broker’s records.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.