Anchoring Bias in Trading When Your Entry Price Changes Your Decision
Two traders hold one MES long under the same exit rule. One has an open gain and the other has an open loss at the decision point. First read the chart with the fills hidden, then reveal each one.
Quick Answer
Anchoring bias occurs when a reference price, such as your entry or a prior high, carries more weight than the current evidence warrants. To check for it, record the action your written rule calls for before looking at your fill price or open P&L in review.
Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.
Start judging closes after 9:25 ET. The 9:55 candle closes exactly at 6,002.00. The 10:00 candle closes at 6,001.75, the first close below the exit line. The 10:20 rebound is later evidence.
Make the decision before revealing the fill
In this fictional exercise, both positions are already open at 9:25 a.m. ET. From that point the plan calls for an exit after a five-minute close strictly below 6,002.00. An existing protective stop sits at 5,999.75. The 9:55 candle closes on the line. The 10:00 candle closes one tick below it, so the close-based exit rule has triggered.
Record the prescribed action as of 10:00. Then select each fill scenario. A 6,001.25 fill marks a $2.50 gross gain at 6,001.75, while a 6,004.25 fill marks a $12.50 gross loss. The distance from the current mark to the protective stop is two points, or $10 for one MES before execution costs, in both cases. The exit signal gives you a time to act under the plan. An order record supplies the realized fill price.
At 10:20 price prints back above both fills. If a trader ignored the exit signal to wait for a return to the entry price, log the deviation even though price eventually recovered. The trader at 10:00 had no access to that later candle.
Check whether the reference price belongs in the rule
Entry price matters when you calculate trade risk, fees and realized P&L. A preset rule can also use it, for instance by requiring a defined favorable move before a breakeven adjustment. A previous session high can belong in a setup when the plan explains how to use it.
Flag a possible anchor when a number takes over without new evidence or an applicable rule. Examples include waiting for your fill after the exit condition fires, treating a price as cheap only because it is below last week’s high, or moving a target to a round number after opening the trade. Write down which market observation or planned condition justified the change while it was still knowable.
Audit decisions in your trading journal
During replay or review, hide fill and P&L labels while leaving the price chart and written exit rule visible. Record the rule, time, evidence and action you would take. Reveal the fill and P&L, then record whether and why your answer changed. Use this exercise outside live order management so you can still see the account and order information you need during execution.
Include every case with a documented rule, including trades where both passes agree. Record missing rules or missing evidence separately. Count changed decisions and note which ones the written plan actually allowed. If a rule explicitly depends on entry price, supply its required input and score that rule as written. An exit price by itself cannot tell you why a trader acted.
A laboratory study by Frydman and Rangel varied how prominently stock purchase prices were displayed and observed changes in participants’ selling behavior. The replay exercise here uses the idea of changing what is visible to isolate one decision. Its fictional results measure neither a futures edge nor the effect of hiding prices in live trading.
Sources
Official References
Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.
Is a breakeven stop always a sign of anchoring bias?
A prewritten breakeven adjustment with a defined trigger can be part of a trading plan. For an audit, compare the actual adjustment with the trigger, timing and cost assumptions in that plan.
How are anchoring bias and the disposition effect related?
Anchoring describes how a reference price influences a decision. The disposition effect describes a tendency to realize gains more readily than losses. An entry-price anchor can contribute to that pattern, and a single exit cannot establish the motive.
Risk Disclosure
Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.
TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.
Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.