TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Trading Psychology

Brett Steenbarger’s Solution-Focused Trading Find a Decision Worth Repeating

In TraderFeed, Brett Steenbarger writes about looking for exceptions to recurring trading problems. This independent TradeReign exercise applies that idea to premature entries after a loss. The prices, journal sample and entry rule are fictional.

Quick Answer

Pick a recurring mistake, then review comparable situations where you avoided it. Write down the specific action that helped, and test whether you can repeat it on new decisions. Use the journal to keep the decision and its outcome separate.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides
Comparison

Find the exception to the usual mistake

Three sample journal rows use the same entry rule and follow a stopped trade. The row to study is the one where the urge was present and the trader still waited.

Situation
What the trader did
What to take from it
Urge to enter early
Entered while the candle was above the line, before the close.
Record the trigger and the premature submission.
Urge to enter early
Read the value at the completed close before opening the order ticket.
Test whether reading the close helps again when the urge returns.
No urge to enter early
Waited without changing the normal routine.
Keep the decision in your journal and review separately from the urge-present sample.

Identify what happened before the order

Start with a specific problem, such as entering before a five-minute bar closes after a stopped trade. Pull up past decisions with the same rule, setup and recent-loss context. Look for an occasion when you felt the urge and waited anyway. Check the order time against the bar’s closing time.

In this MES exercise, review the next entry from 10:05 ET. The plan requires a completed five-minute close strictly above 6,004.00. In the bar ending at 10:10, price trades at 6,005.25 but closes at 6,003.75. While the candle is forming, hold off opening an order ticket until you can write down the completed close. At 10:15, the bar closes at 6,004.50 and satisfies the exercise test.

Suppose you noticed the urge in both bars and still waited for each close. Record that as the behavior to repeat. The rules can be followed even when the later trade loses. Record any actual fill separately from the chart signal.

Compare an intrabar move with a completed close

Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.

The 10:10 ET candle trades above the level and closes below it. The 10:15 close is the first completed candle above 6,004.00 in the review window.

Test the same action on new opportunities

Use a short instruction you can carry into replay. If you want to enter before the candle closes, record the final close first and then check the written entry criterion. Log the urge when it occurs, the close time, and whether an order was submitted early. Include the bars that fail the entry rule when you score whether you waited.

Suppose you waited in two of six past urge-present opportunities. You then use the written instruction and wait in four of six comparable replay opportunities. Report two of six and four of six with the setup and review period. Keep opportunities without the urge as a separate count, so a calmer sample cannot by itself make the response look better.

Review the two exceptions in the later sample. If the trader recorded the close only after submitting, move the prompt earlier in the routine. Repeat on a fresh set of practice decisions. This comparison measures whether the action repeated under similar conditions.

Build a daily trading report card

Steenbarger describes traders giving themselves a grade and explaining the evidence behind it. Adapt that idea by picking one behavior before the session. For this exercise, score whether you waited for a completed five-minute close before submitting an entry order whenever price traded above your entry level with all other setup conditions satisfied.

Copy these fields into your journal. Use one row for each time the rule applies.

Session and setup | Candidate bar close time | Close qualified? | First entry order time or skipped | Pass, miss or unknown | Evidence | Next practice action

On a fictional replay day, you wait for the close and skip two failed breakouts. On a third candidate, you submit early. The bar later closes above the level and the trade makes money. Record two passes and one miss, or two of three. For the next session, practice writing down the completed close before opening the order ticket.

A flat session can still contain two passes if two candidates appeared and you correctly skipped both. If there were zero candidates, record zero opportunities and leave the grade blank. If a candidate was present and the order timestamp is missing, record it as unknown and show the count alongside the grade. For example, report two passes out of three scorable decisions with one additional unknown.

Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

Steenbarger on finding solutions to trading problemsHis explanation of looking for exceptions to recurring patterns.Solution Focused Trading on TraderFeedSteenbarger’s public article on the approach.Grading Your Trading on TraderFeedSteenbarger explains how traders use grades and feedback to review their performance.The Daily Trading Coach from WileyThe publisher’s overview of Steenbarger’s self-coaching book.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Compare trading psychology authors

Find a book and exercise for the behavior you want to practice.

Build a futures trading journal

Record the setup, decision time, order and outcome.

Review your weakest response to tilt

Compare repeatable behaviors across sessions with Jared Tendler’s Inchworm Concept.

FAQ

Common Questions

What is solution-focused trading?

In Steenbarger’s application, look for exceptions to recurring problems, identify what you did that helped, and practice that action again.

How do I identify a useful exception in my trading journal?

Find a setup where the usual trigger was present and you acted according to the plan. Confirm the action and timing using records you had before the outcome was known.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.