TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Trading Psychology

Jared Tendler’s Mental Hand History for Trading Work Backward From One Recurring Mistake

Jared Tendler developed the Mental Hand History to examine the assumptions behind recurring mistakes. This independent TradeReign example applies that idea to one fictional MES trade, then turns the journal entry into a replay test.

Quick Answer

Start with a specific decision, such as closing a winner before your exit rule was met. Write what you saw, what you expected would happen, and why that expectation felt convincing. Turn what you learn into a response you can test the next time the same trigger appears.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides

Reconstruct what you knew when you clicked

In this exercise you buy one MES at 6,000.00 with a stop at 5,997.00 and a target at 6,005.00. The written exercise plan calls for a bracket exit. The previous two simulated trades lost. At 10:05 ET, price has pulled back to 6,002.00 and you close manually to protect $10 of open profit before costs. Neither bracket level has traded since entry.

Stop your own replay at the decision and record the visible facts before advancing. Here the pullback and the two earlier losses are facts. The thought that another loss is about to happen is a prediction. Price eventually trades through the target in this fictional path. That later information belongs in the outcome column.

Find the moment the trade plan changed

Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.

A fictional MES long at 6,000.00 is closed at 6,002.00 during the 10:05 ET decision. The stop is untouched at that point. Price reaches the planned target later.

Write a short explanation you can test

What set it off? I checked open P&L as price pulled back from its first move above three points of open profit. What made the manual exit feel necessary? After two losses, I wanted this trade to end green so I could feel back in control. Why might that reasoning be unreliable? The previous two trades changed my mood and the session P&L. My recorded plan had no exit condition keyed to either.

What would a better response look like? When I notice myself checking open P&L to decide whether to bail, I’ll read the written exit conditions and check the chart and order status. If the planned orders are working and no written exit condition has been met, I’ll leave the simulated bracket in place. If I think the setup needs a new exit condition, I’ll write it down for a separate test.

That explanation is a working hypothesis. If your real review shows that you routinely exceed your intended size or that your exit rules are too vague to verify, repair the sizing or rule definition and review the next batch of decisions. Pick an explanation that accounts for when the mistake actually appears.

Count comparable triggers across fresh replays

Write the trigger before replay. For this example you could use the first five-minute candle that closes at least one point below the prior candle’s close after open profit reaches three points, while neither bracket level has traded. Log one qualifying pullback per fresh trade, whether you checked the rule, and whether you closed early. Keep no-trigger trades in their own tally so they don’t dilute the early-exit rate.

For example, you manually exited on four of six qualifying pullbacks in a baseline batch, then on two of seven after practicing the response. Record both fractions and the number of no-trigger trades. That is a small practice sample. Use it to decide what to rehearse next and track net P&L separately to evaluate an exit rule.

Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

Jared Tendler’s tools and worksheetsTendler explains why he created the Mental Hand History and links to his materials.The Mental Game of TradingTendler’s book on recurring trading errors and how to investigate their causes.CME Micro E-mini S&P 500 specificationsThe $5 point value used in the fictional example.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Jared Tendler’s Inchworm Concept

Map best, typical, and worst responses to a recurring trigger.

Compare two futures paths after the same early-exit urge

See how following the same rule can lead to different outcomes.

Why traders close trades too early

Review how to tell an unplanned exit from a planned one.

FAQ

Common Questions

What is the difference between a Mental Hand History and a trading journal?

A trade journal can record fills, size, fees, and rule adherence. A Mental Hand History goes deeper on a recurring mistake and examines the reasoning that made the decision feel right in the moment.

Can I do a Mental Hand History on a winning trade?

Yes. This example makes money on the manual exit. The useful question is why the trader departed from a previously written rule.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.