TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Trading Psychology

Tom Hougaard’s Best Loser Wins Practice the Decision After a Loss

Hougaard writes about the discomfort of taking a loss and the anxiety of giving back an open profit. These independent TradeReign exercises put both decisions into futures replay using fictional prices and exercise rules.

Quick Answer

Judge a stopped trade against the plan you had when you entered. Then score the decision that follows. A loss taken at the planned exit can be followed by an unplanned re-entry, even when the next trade makes money.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides

Rehearse the decision before the session

Hougaard describes reviewing a presentation of past trades, mistakes, and reminders to prepare for the day ahead. Build a short version from your own journal. Choose one screenshot where you took a planned loss and one where you felt tempted to change the next order. Crop both at the moment you had to decide.

Write the order you would be allowed to place on each screenshot, including when you would stay flat. For example, after a confirmed stop fill, write down the time you went flat, the first eligible review time, and the fresh entry condition. Reveal the next candles only after recording the answer. Use the same setup criteria on a replay following a winner to see whether the previous result is changing your decision.

If you could recite your rule but still changed the order, mark the first visible sign of the change. That might be moving your cursor to the buy button while the reset is active. The next morning, rehearse what to do at that cue, such as checking the time and writing down the next eligible review.

Write down the next decision before you reveal the rebound

Start with a fictional one-MES long at 6,000.00 and a planned stop at 5,997.50. At $5 per point the planned price loss is $12.50 before fees and slippage. The bar ending at 10:00 ET trades through the stop. For this exercise assume the simulator confirms the position is flat at 10:00. Record the simulator’s actual exit price in your own replay.

The exercise requires ten minutes flat before reviewing another entry. It also requires a fresh five-minute close strictly above 6,001.00 after the wait. At 10:05 the rebound closes at 6,001.25. Pause and record whether an order is eligible. At 10:10 the wait has ended and the bar closes at 6,000.75. The earlier close cannot carry forward as a fresh entry. The next qualifying close in this chart comes at 10:45.

If you want to chase the 10:05 bar, write the urge down while the replay is paused. Check whether you would submit the same order if the previous trade had won. Use the written rule to make the exercise decision. The answer can be to stay flat and keep watching.

Score the stop and the next order separately

Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.

The stop is reached in the bar ending at 10:00 ET. A rebound at 10:05 is inside the reset. The first trade review under the exercise rule is at 10:10, when the bar closes below the fresh-entry level.

Score exit adherence and re-entry adherence separately

For each stopped-out practice trade, record the planned exit, actual exit, time the position went flat, and the earliest eligible review time. Add the next signal time, whether it qualified, and whether you submitted an order. A losing trade can pass both checks. A rebound trade can make money and still fail the second check.

Suppose you keep the planned exit eight times in ten simulated losses. On six of those ten occasions you also follow the new-entry rule. Report eight of ten for exit adherence and six of ten for re-entry adherence. Review the two scores independently to find the habit that needs work. Keep net results and unresolved fills in their own columns.

Practice the urge to take profits too early

In his public psychology manual, Hougaard describes a trader who cuts a winner to protect the profit, then feels desperate to get back in. To study that moment, assume a one-MES long fills at 6,000.00. Set a fictional stop at 5,998.00 and target at 6,006.00. For this drill, the written plan allows an exit only at the stop or target.

Pause at 10:15 ET before comparing the charts below. Price has pulled back from above 6,003.75 and closes at 6,003.00, with $15 in open profit before costs. Write down why you want to exit using the information available then. Check whether any exit condition in your written plan has been met. In your own replay, hide the next candles until you’ve written down the answer.

Assume fills at the stated prices for comparison. Exiting at 6,003.00 would earn $15 in either branch. Following the written plan would earn $30 in the target branch and lose $10 in the stop branch, before fees and slippage. The same early exit would violate this drill’s rule in both cases, including the branch where it improves the result.

For each replay, record the stated exit condition, what price had done when you wanted out, and whether you followed the plan. Review net results separately. If the same pullback repeatedly makes you want to exit, write a specific alternative exit rule before trying it on a fresh set of replays.

Compare two outcomes after the same urge to exit

Synthetic MES 5-minute candles. Times are bar closes in ET.

After the 10:15 decision, the fictional market advances and reaches the target in the bar ending at 10:45 ET.

Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

Best Loser Wins from Harriman HouseThe publisher’s summary of Hougaard’s book on the mental side of trading.Tom Hougaard’s public psychology manualHougaard describes treating trading psychology as something to practice regularly.Hougaard’s public articles on tradingThe Best Loser Wins article describes reviewing past trades and reminders before the session.CME Micro E-mini S&P 500 contract specificationsCheck the $5 point value used in the example.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Calculate the risk of adding to a winner

See how a second MES changes the stop result and the open-profit giveback.

Practice keeping the original stop

Compare two possible outcomes after the same stop decision.

Map and improve your trading C-game

Use Jared Tendler’s Inchworm idea to track an earlier response to tilt.

Journal what made an early exit feel necessary

Use a Mental Hand History to turn the reason for a rule break into a replay test.

Set and review a trading cooldown

Compare timer start time, expiry and new-entry eligibility.

FAQ

Common Questions

What does Best Loser Wins mean in this exercise?

Treat a planned loss as part of following the setup. Check whether you kept the exit rule and whether the next order met its own criteria.

Did Tom Hougaard teach the ten-minute reset used here?

The ten-minute reset and the MES prices are TradeReign exercise rules. Hougaard’s book supplies the theme of practicing how you respond to losses.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.