TradeReign
Back to HomeEducation HubCompatibilityAboutDisclosures
Futures Order Flow

Unfinished Auctions on Footprint Charts Read the Bid and Ask at the Bar’s Extreme

A footprint shows how much traded on each side at each price inside one bar. A TPO profile shows which time periods reached each price. The two charts can describe the same price differently because they measure different things.

Quick Answer

On a completed bid × ask footprint bar, traders commonly call the high or low an unfinished auction when both volume cells at that exact extreme are greater than zero. A finished high commonly shows zero bid volume and a finished low shows zero ask volume. Confirm the data and row settings before interpreting a zero.

Start 7-Day TrialMore Guides

Read both cells

Check the bid and ask volume at the same high or low. A diagonal ratio answers a different question.

Verify the feed

Use a completed bar, one tick per price row and the same method for classifying trades.

Compare with TPO

Two time periods can reach the same high even when their footprints show different volume at the extreme.

Synthetic ES Footprint

Two five-minute bars at the same high and low

These fictional bars end at 10:30 and 11:00 a.m. ET. Each row is one ES tick and each cell shows bid volume × ask volume in contracts.

Price
10:30 bar
11:00 bar
6,006.00 · high
4 × 23 · unfinished
0 × 19 · finished
6,005.75
12 × 31
11 × 25
6,005.50
21 × 10
14 × 19
6,005.25 · low
18 × 0 · finished
16 × 3 · unfinished

Read the extremes independently. The first bar has an unfinished high and a finished low. The second has a finished high and an unfinished low.

Identify unfinished auctions at the bar high or low

Read the actual extreme price of a closed bar. In the 10:30 bar, 4 contracts traded on the bid side and 23 on the ask side at 6,006.00. That is two-sided trade at the high under the footprint convention. The 11:00 bar shows 16 bid and 3 ask at its low, so that low also qualifies.

The volume on both sides at 6,005.75 is inside the bar’s range. It can matter to an order-flow read, but it does not qualify as an unfinished extreme. Wait for the bar to finish, since a new high or low can turn a candidate row into an interior row.

Check the footprint in NinjaTrader and TradingView

In NinjaTrader Desktop, use Order Flow Volumetric bars with Bid Ask delta and the Bid Ask chart style. Set Ticks per level to 1 and Size filter to 0 for this comparison. Verify that your provider supplies historical bid and ask tick data. The Up Down Tick mode uses trade-price changes to classify volume.

In TradingView, choose Volume footprint with Buy and Sell display and use a one-tick row size. Check whether Tick-based calculation is enabled. The standard mode classifies volume by intrabar price direction. Tick-based mode uses aggressor data when available and can fall back to bid and ask proximity or tick direction. Match the dated contract, session and bar boundaries before comparing platforms. If the source data or aggregation differs, treat the displayed cells as evidence for that chart’s calculation only.

A zero and a blank cell may have different meanings. Check the display, filters and history before recording a genuine zero. These rows represent classified traded volume. Resting bids and offers in the order book are a separate measure.

Compare an unfinished auction with a TPO poor high

Suppose the 10:30 bar falls in the B period of a 30-minute regular-session TPO profile and the 11:00 bar falls in C. If 6,006.00 remains the session high and only B and C reach it, the profile can show a flat B C high with no excess above. That is a poor high under the convention described by ShadowTrader, even though the later footprint shows zero bid volume at that price.

When journaling a revisit, define the outcome first. For example, log whether a later bar trades at the exact footprint price before the session ends, and record cases with no touch. Track a ShadowTrader-style TPO repair separately by looking for a later regular session to trade through the prior poor extreme. A footprint tag on its own provides no probability of a revisit and no entry or exit rule.

Sources

Official References

Platform details on this page were checked against these official resources.

Sierra Chart Numbers BarsDocuments nonzero bid and ask highlighting at the high or low and explains zero-volume checks.NinjaTrader Order Flow Volumetric BarsCovers bid and ask columns, tick history, price aggregation and size filtering.TradingView Volume FootprintExplains intrabar and tick-based volume classification.ShadowTrader poor highDefines the flat TPO profile and the regular-session repair convention.
Related Guides

Keep Building the Rule System

Read delta on a TradingView footprint

Compare same-price delta and diagonal imbalances in a worked bar.

See when footprint imbalances form a stack

Check the adjacency rule with two synthetic MES footprints.

Check bid and ask history in NinjaTrader

Distinguish Bid Ask classification from Up Down Tick.

Check a poor high and its repair

Compare an overnight cross, an exact touch and a regular-session extension.

Set up a TPO chart

Match the period, session and price increment before comparing profiles.

FAQ

Common Questions

Is an unfinished auction the same as a poor high or poor low?

An unfinished footprint auction uses bid and ask volume at the extreme of one bar. A poor high or low uses repeated TPO periods and a lack of excess at the edge of the session profile. One can appear without the other.

Does a zero mean no one traded at the high?

A zero bid cell with a positive ask cell means the chart counted ask-side trades at that price and classified none as bid-side. Check trade classification, row size, volume filters and data coverage first.

Does price have to return to an unfinished auction?

No. A label describes the completed bar. If you track revisits, define the price and observation window and retain every instance, including levels that remain untouched.

Risk Disclosure

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. TradeReign is a trading-discipline and rule-enforcement application. It does not provide trading advice, trade signals, investment recommendations, or performance guarantees.

TradeReign is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant, or investment advisor.

Futures trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Only risk capital - money that can be lost without jeopardizing financial security or lifestyle - should be used for trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.